At first I really struggled with what to get Dave, but in the end was really excited with what I purchased. I gave him two leather luggage tags with his initials monogrammed on it, a passport holder with his initials monogrammed, and a leather business card holder from Pottery Barn. He's traveling a lot lately for his job so I figured these things were useful, masculine, and professional. Here are some ideas for you so you don't have to struggle like I did.
As great as my gift guide is I went in a completely different direction for Dave. Personally he either has one of each of these items or would not use them (leather jacket in Florida? I think not. And he's not a journal kind of guy).
I've also compiled a little cheat sheet for the first ten years of marriage and what their corresponding traditional gifts are.
I feel like next year I'm going to have to really get creative since flowers and/or fruits don't scream MAN GIFT to me. But that's part of the fun!